The Hobbit

[firecat]

I saw The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey today.


I was entertained, and I think it's pretty cool when people can get zillions of dollars to make fanfic movies set in Middle Earth.

I think I recognized some of the plot of Tolkien's book The Hobbit in between the chase and battle scenes. And it works for me that Jackson seems to be setting this up as a prequel to his LOTR films, by putting it in a larger context of Evil Stirring™.

Back a while ago, I went to see Fellowship of the Ring with my girlfriend. When the troll scene in Moria started, she went to the bathroom, which involved walking to the other end of the theater complex. When she came back, the troll scene was still going.

She could have gone to the bathroom about ten times during this movie.

It was very distracting to have Aidan Turner in the movie. (My reaction every time: "Here are a bunch of dwarves, and a hobbit. And Aidan Turner!") If he had had a beard, as Tolkien's dwarves are supposed to, then it wouldn't have been so distracting.

I quite liked the addition of Radagast the Brown as an important character. It almost makes up for Tom Bombadil being cut from the Lord of the Rings movies.

The scene between Bilbo and Gollum was very well done.

Comments

[baerana]

so it sounds like overall, not worth seeing? (Aidan Turner wouldn't be a distraction for me, i have a visual processing disorder that prevents me from recognizing people - it's called prosopagnosia aka face blindness) but i was hoping this wouldn't suck, I liked the hobbit (the book) way better than the lord of the rings or the rest of the trilogy (horror, i know, they'll take my geek card now :) )

[baerana]

btw, totally unrelated, but honest opinion - do i look like a haughty bitch in that icon pic?

[firecat]

No, to me you look serious but not haughty in that pic. I'm quite in favor of women not feeling obligated to smile for photographs.

[firecat]

What I left out of my review is that I think that Peter Jackson's team does a very good job of capturing the way I imagined Middle-Earth and its characters would look, and that means a lot to me. Also I think the music is really good, which also matters a lot to me. So even when he kinda goes nuts with the battle scenes, the movies are still worth seeing for me. If you don't care as much about those things, you might want to skip it.

[laughingrat]

I reckon I should see it, but I tried to reread the book recently and...found it boring. D: The years have not treated me kindly, apparently. But since it sounds like the movie bears little resemblance to the book...

[firecat]

It's definitely more lively than the book...

[flarenut]

It would have made a really nice two-hour movie. Are we being set up for the video games, where you get points for bouncing off more levels of the Definitely Not A Fantasy Version of an Exploding Bond Villain Set?

I also really loved the scene between Bilbo and Gollum, although I was pissed at the whole homily thing about how swords are important for whom you don't slay with them.

Did you like Radagast? He annoyed the crud out of me with his twittering, which seemed to not really go with his status as a Great Wizard. (And the references to him during the Meeting At Lothlorien. Grr.)

In some ways, I think the movie suffered from being a prequel rather than the first of a series. Particularly Lothlorien/Rivendell seemed wrong to me -- Although I can see the justification for rendering the place along Crouching Tiger lines in LOTR, in the Hobbit it was plain old Rivendell, and my impression was that the elves were much more celtic/saxon, at least in Bilbo's understanding. Anybody else?

[firecat]

I did like Radagast. Oddly, he reminded me of The Regent in Babylon 5, whom I read as a superficially silly person with depths.

[flarenut]

OK, I can understand that.

[starcat-jewel.livejournal.com]

Kili has a beard! It's a short beard rather than a long one, but he's got a full mustache and beard. Fili's beard is rather short as well. I think this may be to demarcate them as being the "youngsters" in the group.

[firecat]

Fili has a beard, but I would call what Kili has a three-day stubble.

[klwalton.livejournal.com]

I agree with most of this post. But? Radagast is not that... goofy. That jarred.

Loved the riddle scene so much.

Hated the typical Peter Jackson let's-drag-out-the-battle-scenes-as-long-as-possible stuff.

I am still *pissed* that the Scouring of the Shire was cut from the LOTR movies. I mean, really? That was the whole damn *point*!

Loved the Great Goblin. Stunning!

Sort of not liking the embellishments. That said? It could have been far, far worse. Which is about what I said about LOTR. Peter pissed me off on a couple of points, but taken as a whole? I'm good.

[firecat]

There was something about Radagast that reminded me of The Regent in Babylon 5, another apparently foolish but actually pretty smart character. I think that's why the goofiness didn't bother me as much as it might have otherwise.

Yep on the Scouring. I suppose he might be saving that for subsequent movies...

Overall I preferred the LOTR movies to this one, but I might come to feel differently.

[klwalton.livejournal.com]

Overall I preferred the LOTR movies to this one, but I might come to feel differently.

This so very much.

I hope he's saving The Scouring, but I don't hold out much hope.

[starcat-jewel.livejournal.com]

I don't see how the Scouring could be done in the future. Saruman and Wormtongue died at Orthanc.

Jackson chose to present the Scouring as a vision of a possible future, which has now been closed off by the actions taken in the present. And frankly, I think he made the right choice.

[klwalton.livejournal.com]

Also? Aidan Turner is SO DAMN CUTE, I don't *mind* that I keep saying, "Oooh, Aidan Turner!" Because, cute. DAMN cute!

:):)

[firecat]

Yes, he's adorable.