"be pet" vs "be petted" unscientific analysis

[firecat]

It's looking to me like a substantial proportion of the people who think "I like to be pet behind the ears" is correct have spent a certain amount of time in Michigan, Windsor, or Minnesota, or know people from there.

Then again, I grew up in Michigan (left in 1981) and I never heard it there, that I recall.

Comments

[ljgeoff.livejournal.com]

I was one of the "be pet" group (UP of mich); "be petted" sounds wrong. But then, I also say "she lay down" instead of "she laid down."

[pameladean]

And that is actually correct, unless you're talking about wine. For fussy values of "correct," anyway. The past tense of "lie" is "lay" and the past tense of "lay" (pesky, pesky, pesky verb as it is) is "laid." Forgive me if you know all this.

I've lived in Minnesota for years, but I didn't grow up here, and I don't know all that many people who did. And you know, it's amazing how the past tense of "pet" will just not come up during years of conversation.

P.

[firecat]

I think this:

"she lay down" is correct past tense of "to lie".

"Laid" is the past tense of "to lay." If I hear "She laid down," I ask "She laid what down?"

[laurellei.livejournal.com]

I do that too. But then I am one of those picky people who correct people for asking can they do some such rather than may they. *shrug*

[ljgeoff.livejournal.com]

I'm trying to think of what usage Word kept correcting me -- "She lay her hand on his cheek." Yeah, it wanted "laid". But "laid" just doesn't sound right to me. *shrugs* I dunno why!