who gets to be considered a fat activist

[firecat]

I distrust most conversations about who gets to be in [whatever] camp and who doesn't, and what's the "real" way of doing something and what isn't. Mostly I think they cause more harm than good. So I feel uncomfortable with the comments I'm going to make, but I'm going to make them anyway.

http://www.ficklefingeroffat.com/ is a new blog by a person who was a famous spokesperson for fat acceptance. The person is now blogging about her attempts to lose weight. This has caused some controversy at shapelyprose and among some other fat-acceptance bloggers.

There are various takes on the subject, and I'm not going to list them all here. I'm going to discuss just one of them that came up in a friend's locked post. It was said that size-acceptance is about "live and let live," and suggested that it was hypocritical for size-acceptance advocates to criticize "a personal decision."

My comment was:

Thing is, it's not just "a personal decision" when it's undertaken in a public blog by a famous spokesperson for fat-acceptance.

The person has every right to do what they are doing, but writing a blog about their deliberate weight loss attempts discredits them as a spokesperson for fat-acceptance, in my mind.

therotund put it better here (emphasis mine):

A lot of the comments I have seen, both here and at Shapely Prose, seem to want to define Fat Activism as doing whatever the hell you want to do with your body. But that isn’t Fat Activism. That is body autonomy, which is a component of Fat Activism.

and

Does this mean [people who are dieting] cannot work toward changing social perceptions of fat people? No. But if you are a fat person who is publicly dieting, that is going to inform your message and reinforce the idea that fat people can and should lose weight by just trying hard enough. Does this mean you cannot appreciate and love other fat people? No. But it does send a message of “fat is okay for you but not for me” which kind of undermines the message of acceptance.

Comments

Re: An odd thought

[cassidyrose.livejournal.com]

Ditto on the knee stuff. My family has shitty knees. I have had shitty knees (congenital problems) all my life and significant knee pain since high school (when I weighed all of 130lbs). I was a serious athlete in high school (tennis and swimming) but my knees were so bad that getting up and down stairs was a problem. My knees got better after I quite engaging in sports so heavily. Dance, these past ten years, of course, did not help, and I noticed a signifcant improvement in knee pain when I took a dance hiatus at the end of my pregnancy and a few months post-partum. FWIW, our smallest dancer has the worst knees of any of us and we have had several dancers heavier/bigger than me who could do all sorts of whacky knee stuff that hurts me to even think about.

So, yeah. I have never believed that knee pain is all, or even mostly, or even partially, about one's weight/size.